Hearing Details: Monday 19 May 2014 (5pm AEST, 9am SAST, 7pm NZST)
Judicial Hearing Chairman: Jannie Lubbe SC
Player: Ed O'Donoghue
Team: Reds
Position: Lock
Date of Incident: 17 May 2014
Nature of Offence: 10.4 (m) Acts contrary to good sportsmanship
Elapsed time in match when offence occurred: 79th minute


A SANZAR Judicial Hearing has found Ed O'Donoghue of the Reds not guilty of contravening Law 10.4 (m) Acts contrary to good sportsmanship after he was issued a red card during a Super Rugby match at the weekend.

No further sanction has been imposed on the player and the red card has been removed from his record.

The incident occurred during the match between the Reds and Rebels at Suncorp Stadium in Brisbane on Saturday 17 May 2014. The referee for the match, Steve Walsh, on advice from the television match official, issued a red card for the incident which occurred in the 79th minute.

The SANZAR Judicial Hearing held via video conference on Monday 19 May 2014 at 5pm AEST, 9am SAST, 7pm NZST and was heard by Jannie Lubbe SC who was assisted by former professional player, Paul Thomson.

In his finding, Advocate Lubbe ruled the following: 

After careful consideration of all of the evidence, which included written and verbal submissions from the player, the player's representative Mark Martin QC, Scott Higginbotham and match officials, I have found Mr O'Donoghue not guilty.

My finding is supported by these witness statements, in conjunction with medical evidence supplied by the Rebels which indicated no damage had been inflicted upon Mr Higginbotham and furthermore, the player stated that he made no complaint to the referee.

The act of eye gouging generally triggers a reaction from the victim which was not evident in this case and helped support my finding.

Eye gouging is certainly a very serious and unacceptable offence in the game of rugby and any allegation warrants a thorough investigation.

In this instance, having thoroughly reviewed video evidence from numerous angles and the considering witness testimony, I am satisfied that Mr O'Donoghue has not committed the act in question.

No further sanction has been imposed on the player and the red card has been removed from his record.